• Sun. Nov 17th, 2024

Spotted UK

Local News Reports

Who makes the best mince pie in Merseyside?

BySpotted UK

Dec 23, 2023

If Christmas has a taste, it is that of the mince pie. Deliciously spiced fruit covered by a buttery, sweet pastry – it is the epitome of indulgence. And love 'em or hate 'em, at this time of year, they're not going anywhere.

In the run-up to Christmas, many bakers have created their own twist on the little wonders, with some more traditional, and others holding a few surprises and secret ingredients.

Here we have four mince pies from established Merseyside bakeries with only one winner.

READ MORE: Man charged £1k a minute after dropping passengers at Manchester Airport

READ MORE: Much-loved Italian opening new venue in city centre

Homebaked, Anfield

Homebaked mince pie

The Homebaked mince pie is rather traditional in style but it is bloody good.

As soon as the pastry touches the inside of your mouth, it melts into a lovely, buttery, sugary crumb. The mincemeat also tastes great: fruity and spiced with amazing hints of citrus.

The pastry/mincemeat ratio is spot on, allowing you to experience the flavour and texture of both perfectly. This is the pinnacle.

Price: 50p per mince pie

Rating: 5/5

Address: 197-199 Oakfield Rd, Liverpool L4 0UF

The Wild Loaf, Dingle

The Wild Loaf mince pie

Filled with a generous portion of mince, The Wild Loaf's mince pie has a darker pastry than average.

The pastry is quite crunchy, but tastes great. With a delicious, citrusy filling, it is brilliantly boozy – containing brandy and cider, making it a real adults adult mince pie.

The pie tastes extremely homemade and it's evident that much effort and thought went into its creation.

Price: £3 per mince pie

Rating: 4/5

Address: 133 Sefton St, Liverpool L8 4BX

Satterthwaites, Crosby

Satterthwaites mince pie

If you asked me to describe a mince pie from my childhood, I would describe to you the Satties mince pie.

It's soft, buttery, crumbly pastry filled with perfectly spiced fruit. Quite thin, not overly sweet and beautifully basic, this mince pie is completely no-nonsense – and I love it.

Traditional and unpretentious, the pies prove popular with the people of Crosby and the surrounding areas, prompting them to make 13,000 of them in preparation for the festive period.

Price: £5 for 6 mince pies

Rating: 4/5

Address: 51 Coronation Road, Crosby, Liverpool L23 5RE

Greggs

Greggs mince pie

While I love a Greggs, their mince pies are a disappointment.

Much too sweet, the filling is more of a jam. It tasted cheap and processed, and so did the pastry, which had nothing special about it whatsoever. It was also sad to see one of the pies had exploded all over the box, leaving a sticky mess everywhere.

Not awful, but certainly not good, I'll stick to the sausage rolls.

Price: £2.15 for 6 mince pies

Rating: 2/5

So what do you think? Let us know in the comments and follow us on X (formerly Twitter) @LivEchonews

128 faces from Liverpool's nightclubs in the 70s, 80s and 90s

Receive top stories on everything going on in Merseyside including events, shopping and food and drink through our newsletter by signing up here